Two Sides of the COIN: Good Governance vs. Compellence

January 01, 2022 00:44:19
Two Sides of the COIN: Good Governance vs. Compellence
Irregular Warfare Podcast
Two Sides of the COIN: Good Governance vs. Compellence

Jan 01 2022 | 00:44:19

/

Show Notes

In counterinsurgency warfare, how can powerful states reform corrupt or repressive governments into legitimate ones? Our guests on this episode, Jacqueline L. Hazelton and Anne-Marie Slaughter, discuss this fundamental challenge and explain two competing models of counterinsurgency that take different approaches to it. The first is the good governance model, which has dominated both scholarship and COIN practice over recent decades. But the second, the compellence model, might actually better explain COIN success in the past. The discussion concludes with a reflection on both the opportunities and the limits of US power in potential future interventions.

Intro music: "Unsilenced" by Ketsa

Outro music: "Launch" by Ketsa

CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

Other Episodes

Episode

June 30, 2023 00:52:23
Episode Cover

Proxy Warfare, Theory and Practice

Why do states engage in proxy warfare? How does what scholars call principal-agent theory explain the way proxy warfare actually plays out—particularly the challenges...

Listen

Episode

June 03, 2022 00:51:29
Episode Cover

Plan Colombia: Anatomy of a Successful Counterinsurgency Campaign

Plan Colombia has been described as a model of successful counterinsurgency and foreign internal defense at a time when large footprints in Iraq and...

Listen

Episode 0

February 26, 2021 00:49:33
Episode Cover

War Entrepreneurs: Economic Drivers of Insurgency, Terrorism, and Crime

What drives illicit violence by substate groups such as terrorists, insurgents, and criminals—and how can states counter these threats? Our guests in this episode,...

Listen